Winning entries for the Red Square Tolerance Pavilion
By Bustler Editors|
Wednesday, Jan 14, 2015
Related
With all the complexities of the different social, political, and religious beliefs in this world, spreading the value of tolerance is essential. Based on this notion, HMMD had entrants propose design ideas for a Red Square Tolerance Pavilion for Moscow's historic Red Square.
At the end of the ideas competition, three winners were selected from over 120 submissions. Proposals for the temporary structure were evaluated on concept, originality, presentation quality, and most importantly: political and social influence.
Check out the winners below.
1st prize winners: Kiana Jalali, Alessandro Vitale, Matteo Pagani, Marco Merigo
Project summary:
"This project, although seemingly quite simple, carries great potential to spread the message of tolerance. The choice to move the structure away from the center of the square is a strong one, and its location against the Kremlin Wall speaks powerfully. In the space created by this project, visitors are forced to confront the wall's darker past as they are educated about a tolerant future, thus creating a powerful dichotomy.
Throughout the project, there are also a series of framed views from the structure, and even the subtle incline of the facade speaks metaphorically of inviting the public inside. The full transparency within the space, even down to the chosen stair details of transparent treads and risers, continues this idea of welcoming and acceptance. The choice of a white facade in direct contrast to the red brick wall behind is also one that speaks of peace, forgiveness, and hope.
As a temporary pavilion, the removal of this intervention could also be politically charged, as the lack of weathering behind this facade would leave a physical imprint on the wall. This would continue to remind visitors of the power of tolerance, thus embodying the enduring social and political footprint that this competition seeks.
Finally, the provocative ideas put forth in the concept and design of this project are followed elegantly with a presentation that clearly illustrates the desired juxtaposition between the tyranny of the wall and the pure hope for a tolerant future. This is most clearly illustrated with the elevation rendering, which illustrates a glowing white beacon triumphing over a totalitarian past."
For the full project statement, click here.
2nd prize winners: Mesi Koponen, Ida Sandvik
Project summary:
"This project features a series of clever solutions to engaging and sharing the subject of tolerance. The choice to position the pavilion so that it crosses the entire width of the square is successful in its utilitarian nature of intercepting all visitors crossing the square. In this same position it is also forming a metaphorical blockade against the military routes outlined in the paving of the square. The slightly voyeuristic nature of the concept is also provocative in the manner that everyone in the square becomes a participant in educating the public about tolerance. Through many plied layers of colored glass, one's view of the passersby in the square is reduced to a series of silhouettes, which poetically alludes to the fact that without the pretense of our own prejudices (i.e. a clear view of another human being that we can judge), we are all equal.
Aside from the strong and clear ideas incorporated into this project, the presentation itself is equally powerful in its clarity and simplicity. Of particular note is the eloquence of the narrative on the first board, which the judges found to be at the heart of the idea of the competition. Additional noteworthy details reveal themselves as one realizes, for example, that the image on the first board is illustrating a red square, and is yet in philosophical contrast to the Red Square competition site itself.
The project is successful in clearly illustrating an idea that directly confronts intolerance - that everything is not always as it seems - and that it is only through understanding and acceptance that we can embrace tolerance."
For the full project statement, click here.
3rd prize winner: Nicolas Souchko
Project summary: "This project exhibits a straightforward concept that is presented very clearly and represented beautifully. The idea of folding or twisting together various minority groups is quite unique and manifests itself well architecturally. Additionally, the programmatic planning of the pavilion has a refreshing clarity - showing a somewhat religious ascension towards a tolerant enlightenment. Each of the petals contains a different gallery, and as they each fold into each other they reveal a sequence of experiences that culminates in a common central space for gathering and exchanging ideas. The unspoken metaphor of a flower is also present, which sets a tone of growth and beauty.
The contrast between the materiality of this pavilion and the rest of the square, namely the Kremlin Wall, brings a subtle poetry to the scheme. The key image of the presentation shows a series of translucent petals lifting into the air in contrast to the weight of its monolithic red neighbor, which further reinforces the concept of a welcoming and tolerant space that stands directly in front of, and in direct contrast to, the Kremlin Wall.
The presentation itself is also particularly noteworthy, and included some of the highest quality images amongst the entries. These images are successful in conveying how a series of simple architectural moves can successfully set the scene for a didactic and tolerant environment."
For the full project statement, click here.
Share
0 Comments
Comment as :