• Login / Join
  • About
  • •
  • Contact
  • •
  • Advertising
bustler logo
bustler logo
  • News
  • Competitions
  • Events
  • Bustler is powered by Archinect
  • Sign up for Bustler's Email Newsletters

  • Follow these Bustler feeds:

  • Search

    Search in

  • Submit

    What are you submitting?

    News Pitch
    Competition
    Event
  • Login / Join
  • News|Competitions|Events
  • Search
    | Submit
    | Follow
  • Search in

    What are you submitting?

    News Pitch
    Competition
    Event

    Follow these Bustler feeds:

  • About|Contact|Advertising
  • Login / Join

Brutal Destruction: capturing concrete architecture's dying moments

By Alexander Walter|

Thursday, Apr 12, 2018

Rey Lopez, Third Church of Christ, Scientist, Washington, D.C., Araldo Cossutta (1970).

Once mighty, often fortress-like structures clad in the accentuated and raw beauty of exposed concrete, more and more examples of the once praised Brutalist movement have fallen out of favor with the general public and had their lifespans cut much shorter than initially anticipated. 

A new photography exhibition opening at pinkcomma gallery in Boston today documents these fragile moments of demise of iconic buildings like the Prentice Women's Hospital by Bertrand Goldberg, Paul Rudolph's Orange County Government Center, or Robin Hood Gardens in London. 

Brutal Destruction is curated by Chris Grimley of Boston-based architecture firm over,under.

Oliver Wainwright, Robin Hood Gardens, London, UK, Alison and Peter Smithson (1972).

Following is the exhibition's description:

"'Monstrosity' appears to be a favorite word for those who wish to bully and belittle architecture into obscurity and, in the more alarming cases, onto a demolition list. We need not look hard to remind ourselves that the term has been used by previous generations to describe Victorian architecture, French Second Empire buildings, and many other styles seen as outmoded within a half-generation of their heyday. Our contempt for the destruction that followed should give us pause in today’s rush to judge the concrete buildings of the mid-twentieth century as unsightly or alien."

Matthew Carbone, Morris A. Mechanic Theatre , Baltimore, MD, John M. Johansen (1967).

"Curated by Chris Grimley of over,under, Brutal Destruction features a collection of photographs by Matthew Carbone, Harlan Erskine, Jason Hood, Rey Lopez, David Schalliol, David Torke, and Oliver Wainwright. These haunting images of buildings in the process of destruction show an architecture once praised, yet now at its most vulnerable a half-century or so after its completion, and vilified to the point of demolition. Suspended between life and death, these buildings remind us of the power that architecture can possess upon its inception, but also of the forces that conspire against it once it is judged to have become old, out-of-shape, obsolete, or ugly."

David Schalliol, Prentice Women’s Hospital, Chicago, IL, Bertrand Goldberg (1975).

"If there is a lesson in seeing concrete masterworks disfigured and demolished, we do not believe it lies in exposing or punishing the hubris of the generation that created them. Rather, the current wave of destruction says more about our own pessimism, the weakness of our potential building legacy, and our lack of patience in finding ways to supersede the cycle of ugliness and make these monstrosities our own."

Harlan Erskine, Orange County Government Center, Goshen, NY, Paul Rudolph (1970).

"Brutal Destruction is part of the ongoing Heroic Project, which also includes the book Heroic: Concrete Architecture and the New Boston (The Monacelli Press, 2015), and the Brutalist Boston Map (Blue Crow Media, 2017)."

David Torke, Shoreline Apartments, Buffalo, NY, Paul Rudolph (1974).

Brutal Destruction opens today, April 12, from 6-9 pm and runs through May 3. The pinkcomma gallery team comprised Chris Grimley, Michael Kubo, and Mark Pasnik. Curatorial Assistant is Shannon McLean and Anna Driscoll is the Exhibit Assistant.

RELATED EVENT Brutal Destruction
RELATED NEWS As Brutalism faces an uncertain future, this exhibition at DAM calls for the style's re-evaluation
RELATED NEWS Photographer captures life in an international Brutalist icon

Related

brutalism ● exhibition ● event ● boston ● massachusetts ● usa ● destruction ● demolition
OverUnder
OverUnder

Share

  • Follow

    3 Comments

  • Paul Puzzello ·  Apr 14, 18 2:27 PM

    Here's another one on the Indiana University Campus in Bloomington, just last week.  The "relocation" by the trustees of a beautiful carillon bell tower to a more "central" part of campus.  Built in 1970.

  • Paul Puzzello ·  Apr 14, 18 2:31 PM

    https://indianapublicmedia.org...

  • PaulRudolphHeritageFdtn
    PaulRudolphHeritageFdtn

    PaulRudolphHeritageFdtn ·  Nov 10, 18 7:56 PM

    The loss of the Paul Rudolph's Shoreline Apartments and the modifications to the Orange County Government Center are horrifying.
  • Comment as :

Brutal Destruction: capturing concrete architecture's dying moments

Eight innovative timber projects honored at 2026 Wood in Architecture Awards

Beautiful brick architecture honored at BRICK AWARD 26

Over $500,000 awarded to architectural discourse projects by Graham Foundation

Best in urban planning recognized at AIA Regional & Urban Design Award 2026

Sponsored Post by Buildner

Re:Form - New Life for Old Spaces / Edition #3 advance registration deadline is approaching!

New architecture and design competitions: IDEAS Awards, UIA-HYP CUP International Student Competition, Vancouver Tall Challenge, and Memorial to the Sixth Extinction

Best small projects chosen at AIA Small Project Award 2026

10 standout sustainable projects honored at AIA COTE Top Ten Award 2026

Sign up for Bustler's Email Newsletters

Best residential architecture of 2026 honored at AIA Housing Award

Best new interiors of 2026 chosen at AIA Interior Architecture Awards

Best global architecture honored at RIBA International Awards 2026

World’s most beautiful airports of 2026 chosen by Prix Versailles

New architecture and design competitions: Brick in Architecture Awards, Study Architecture Student Showcase, N.Y.C. Groceries, and New York High Falls Riverfront Market

SmithGroup’s ‘pioneering’ Philip Merrill Environmental Center wins AIA Twenty-five Year Award

Sponsored Post by Buildner

Museum of Emotions / Edition #8 FINAL registration deadline is in 5 DAYS!

Next page » Loading

Brutal Destruction: capturing concrete architecture's dying moments

By Alexander Walter|

Thursday, Apr 12, 2018

Share

Rey Lopez, Third Church of Christ, Scientist, Washington, D.C., Araldo Cossutta (1970).

Related

brutalism ● exhibition ● event ● boston ● massachusetts ● usa ● destruction ● demolition
OverUnder
OverUnder

Once mighty, often fortress-like structures clad in the accentuated and raw beauty of exposed concrete, more and more examples of the once praised Brutalist movement have fallen out of favor with the general public and had their lifespans cut much shorter than initially anticipated. 

A new photography exhibition opening at pinkcomma gallery in Boston today documents these fragile moments of demise of iconic buildings like the Prentice Women's Hospital by Bertrand Goldberg, Paul Rudolph's Orange County Government Center, or Robin Hood Gardens in London. 

Brutal Destruction is curated by Chris Grimley of Boston-based architecture firm over,under.

Oliver Wainwright, Robin Hood Gardens, London, UK, Alison and Peter Smithson (1972).

Following is the exhibition's description:

"'Monstrosity' appears to be a favorite word for those who wish to bully and belittle architecture into obscurity and, in the more alarming cases, onto a demolition list. We need not look hard to remind ourselves that the term has been used by previous generations to describe Victorian architecture, French Second Empire buildings, and many other styles seen as outmoded within a half-generation of their heyday. Our contempt for the destruction that followed should give us pause in today’s rush to judge the concrete buildings of the mid-twentieth century as unsightly or alien."

Matthew Carbone, Morris A. Mechanic Theatre , Baltimore, MD, John M. Johansen (1967).

"Curated by Chris Grimley of over,under, Brutal Destruction features a collection of photographs by Matthew Carbone, Harlan Erskine, Jason Hood, Rey Lopez, David Schalliol, David Torke, and Oliver Wainwright. These haunting images of buildings in the process of destruction show an architecture once praised, yet now at its most vulnerable a half-century or so after its completion, and vilified to the point of demolition. Suspended between life and death, these buildings remind us of the power that architecture can possess upon its inception, but also of the forces that conspire against it once it is judged to have become old, out-of-shape, obsolete, or ugly."

David Schalliol, Prentice Women’s Hospital, Chicago, IL, Bertrand Goldberg (1975).

"If there is a lesson in seeing concrete masterworks disfigured and demolished, we do not believe it lies in exposing or punishing the hubris of the generation that created them. Rather, the current wave of destruction says more about our own pessimism, the weakness of our potential building legacy, and our lack of patience in finding ways to supersede the cycle of ugliness and make these monstrosities our own."

Harlan Erskine, Orange County Government Center, Goshen, NY, Paul Rudolph (1970).

"Brutal Destruction is part of the ongoing Heroic Project, which also includes the book Heroic: Concrete Architecture and the New Boston (The Monacelli Press, 2015), and the Brutalist Boston Map (Blue Crow Media, 2017)."

David Torke, Shoreline Apartments, Buffalo, NY, Paul Rudolph (1974).

Brutal Destruction opens today, April 12, from 6-9 pm and runs through May 3. The pinkcomma gallery team comprised Chris Grimley, Michael Kubo, and Mark Pasnik. Curatorial Assistant is Shannon McLean and Anna Driscoll is the Exhibit Assistant.

RELATED EVENT Brutal Destruction
RELATED NEWS As Brutalism faces an uncertain future, this exhibition at DAM calls for the style's re-evaluation
RELATED NEWS Photographer captures life in an international Brutalist icon

Share

  • Follow

    3 Comments

  • Paul Puzzello ·  Apr 14, 18 2:27 PM

    Here's another one on the Indiana University Campus in Bloomington, just last week.  The "relocation" by the trustees of a beautiful carillon bell tower to a more "central" part of campus.  Built in 1970.

  • Paul Puzzello ·  Apr 14, 18 2:31 PM

    https://indianapublicmedia.org...

  • PaulRudolphHeritageFdtn

    PaulRudolphHeritageFdtn ·  Nov 10, 18 7:56 PM

    The loss of the Paul Rudolph's Shoreline Apartments and the modifications to the Orange County Government Center are horrifying.
  • Comment as :

Archinect JobsArchinect Jobs

The Archinect Job Board attracts the world's top architectural design talents.

VIEW ALL JOBS POST A JOB

Project Designer / Manager

BuiltIN Studio

Project Designer / Manager

New York, NY, US

Project Architect

Fowlkes Studio

Project Architect

Washington, DC, US

Architectural Designer II

Studio AR&D Architects

Architectural Designer II

Los Angeles, CA, US

Intermediate Architect

GF55 Architects

Intermediate Architect

New York, NY, US

Interior Architect / Interior Designer

Annum Architects (formerly Ann Beha Architects)

Interior Architect / Interior Designer

Boston, MA, US

Senior Architectural Planner

Payette

Senior Architectural Planner

Boston, MA, US

Architectural Designer / Architect (3-5 Years Experience)

Andrew Magnes Architecture

Architectural Designer / Architect (3-5 Years Experience)

Brooklyn, NY, US

Project Manager

The Brooklyn Studio

Project Manager

Brooklyn, NY, US

Technical Designer

D L English Design Studio

Technical Designer

Pasadena, CA, US

Architecture & Design Manager

7th Street Burger

Architecture & Design Manager

New York, NY, US

Next page » Loading